IN 1868 CAME THE FIRST OFFICIAL RESPONSE THAT A NEW COURTHOUSE IN TIOGA COUNTY MIGHT BE IN ORDER. A Tioga County Grand Jury returned an indictment against the existing courthouse charging that it was ‘unsuitable and inconvenient for transaction of legal business.’ In 1870, the Board of Supervisors approved the building of a new courthouse and appropriated $5,000 toward construction costs.
The laying of the cornerstone on August 1, 1871 was attended by thousands of people and was one of the greatest single celebrations in Tioga County history. Special trains began arriving in Owego at 9:30 in the morning. A parade that stretched for a mile ended at 1:30 p.m. Speeches lasted until 5:30 p.m., after which the crowd dispersed to seven hotels and three restaurants for a special banquet.
The bill of fare consisted of broiled corned beef and tongue; roast beef, lamb, veal and pig; a baked veal pie as a side dish; corn, turnips, potatoes, green peas, beets, string beans, onions and squash; relishes of cucumbers, tomatoes and coleslaw; lemon, apple and blackberry pie, tapioca pudding and for dessert melons, peaches and vanilla ice cream.
Two toasts followed the banquet and dancing continued until 4:00 a.m. the following day. Any doubts that the Village may have had about the new courthouse must have been dispelled by the festivities that attended the first day of construction.
As with many buildings and construction projects that are completed today, there were cost over-runs. When the building was finished in the summer of 1873, the total cost, including furnishings, came to $65,000. The building has been well worth the original investment, however. It has served the people of Tioga County for over 100 years and should do so for many years to come.
Source: Hon. Vincent Sgueglia, Tioga County Judge, Owego, N.Y.
PRESIDING JUSTICE CHARLES E. PARKER
PRESIDING JUSTICE CHARLES E. PARKER (1836-1909) WAS BORN IN OWEGO IN TIOGA COUNTY. His father, John M. Parker, was a member of Congress and Justice of the New York Supreme Court. His grandfather, John C. Parker, was also a judge. Presiding Justice Parker graduated from Hobart College in 1857. He read law with his father, was admitted to the bar in 1859 and, after a year of practice in Elmira, returned to Owego. In 1867, he was appointed United States Commissioner for the Northern District of New York and in the same year was elected a member of the State Constitutional Convention. At various times in the 1870s, he was President of the Village of Owego. He was elected County and Surrogate Judge of Tioga County in 1883. He was elected to the Supreme Court in 1887 and reelected in 1901. He was appointed Presiding Justice of the Third Department in October 1895 and served as such until he retired in January, 1907. Presiding Justice Parker was said to be quite eccentric in manner. He had great scorn for fashion and modish clothing, and it took considerable urging on the part of his colleagues on the bench to induce him to wear the robe of a justice. He was very interested in scientific agriculture and owned and operated a large farm near Owego.
Source: Hon. Vincent Sgueglia, Tioga County Judge, Owego, N.Y.