This photo shows a collage of the judges who sat on the New York Court of Appeals from its formation in 1847 through 1901. It is remarkable for two reasons. First, apart from the oil paintings that hang in Court of Appeals Hall, few, if any, historians were aware that photogravure portraits of every judge who served on the court of appeals in the 19th Century, including the pre-Civil war period, were assembled and photographed. Second, the image shows that each judge’s likeness is affixed to a cameo that states the name of the judge, the county where he lived, and the dates on which he served on the Court of Appeals.
Only a person with a deep love for the Court of Appeals and legal history would have undertaken (in the pre-internet aga) the laborious and painstaking task of assembling the images of the judges, affixing them to individual cameos, and then photographing them all together. It appears that this man was Francis M. Finch, a former Judge of the Court of Appeals (1880-1895), Dean of Cornell Law School (1891-1903), President of the New York State Bar Association (1900), and trusted friend and advisor to Erastus Cornell, the founder of Cornell. In addition to his myriad legal accomplishments, Finch was a renowned poet, whose best-known poem “The Blue and the Gray” (1867), written in remembrance of the dead of the American Civil War, helped popularize the spirit of reconciliation that shaped early Memorial Day (originally Decoration Day). Below is a plaque in Finch’s honor that still hangs on a wall at Cornell Law School.
In 1901, then-Dean Finch donated the 51 cameo portraits to the law school. At or about the same time, New York City publisher “W.S. Brown” photographed the 51 cameo portraits.
